The Real Time Web Makes Your Life Safer
Published by MartinVarsavsky.net in General with No Comments
People frequently tell me that I should not disclose so much information about myself as it could potentially be used by criminals, kidnappers and the like to harm me or my family. Interestingly, it is mostly my German friends who tend to argue this point. Germans, as Americans, seem to have a skewed allocation of risk, worrying too much about unlikely risks, and being careless about others. I have German friends who seriously speak to me about the danger of being kidnapped and then go on the autobahn and drive 200km/h without worries.
I think differently. I believe that being public about your life, disclosing your address, your location, your habits, and learning a great deal about the habits of others, is not necessarily adding risk to your life. First of all, I should clarify that I live in Spain and that I have not heard of a single recent kidnapping case in Spain. So I don’t worry about kidnappings. If I lived in my native Argentina, for example, I would be writing a different post. But in Spain, as everywhere, there is common crime and being part of the real time web makes it more likely, for example, for criminals to find out where my home is. My home has been published in magazines, appears on Google Earth/Maps and now that I have started taken photography lessons, I have published many pictures of our home as well. So is that a risk? Overall, are we safer or less safe if we frequently blog, use Twitter, Facebook, and Google Latitude? I think that the real time web helps me lead a safer life and I even include Latitude in this. Google Latitude shares my location in real time with others.
Recently, we were debating safety and Latitude with some friends and the comment was “well if you share your location criminals know where to mug you”. But while it is true that sharing your location may add risk to your life, I think that when people speak of dangers in life, they tend to think too highly of criminality as a risk, and not about other more probable risks for which knowing your location is actually a big plus: examples having a heart attack or falling unconscious while being alone. Many people are terrified at the thought of being murdered by a stranger in their own home and sharing their location on Latitude may scare them even more. But it turns out that being murdered is an extremely unlikely event, and that even when it happens, that most people who get murdered at their home are murdered by people they know. So sharing your location, your habits and your pictures may in some cases increase your risk profile, but overall sharing lowers your risk profile if you correlate risk to likelihood.
Sharing is like wearing a seat belt. Yes, in some cases it may strangle you, but overall it lowers your risk profile. Moreover, in Europe, for example, it is much more likely that if anyone murders you it is yourself in the form of suicide or a lethal accident. Acute depression, drunk driving, are much more common than crime or murder and this is self inflicted damage for which location sharing may save your life. And not only sharing your location but simply sharing your anxieties or problems may lower your risk of actually committing suicide. So if we consider risk anything bad that may happen to you think Latitude or sharing your location with friends and work associates does make your life safer. In my case, for example, I do a lot of mountain biking, with friends or alone, and I always take my mobile device with Latitude. Because even if you are with friends on fast descents everyone goes his own way and going back up to search for a friend is a slow process. In 1998 I had a serious accident mountain biking and it took half an hour of me bleeding to find me. Same with skiing, I see Latitude connected to an iPhone/Blackberry/Android with GPS as a real safety tool.
Now in terms of all other risks the real time web does help avoid risks or getting into trouble. Through Facebook you can track diseases real time, you can get medical advise from friends having similar problems, with other social networks that are geared towards medical users like 23andme (I am an investor) you share your most intimate genetic information with friends, but then you can cooperate in avoiding and treating medical conditions. In general terms I have no doubt that leading a life of isolation does make the likelihood that you will have poorly treated medical problems greater than leading a very social life.
Lastly, there is Twitter. While we don’t have kidnappers in Madrid we do have terrorists who occasionally blow things and sometimes people up. Twitter is the fastest way to get news real time on anything related to terrorism. Whenever something bad happens you see it fly through Twitter. Before Twitter you had to call 30 friends to tell them you were spared or you were well. Now it’s just a Tweet away.
Bottom line? If you want to lead a safer life join the real time web.
PS: I do recognize that this is an anecdotal article and I welcome proofs for or against the argument that sharing increases or decreases your risk profile.
Follow Martin Varsavsky on Twitter: twitter.com/martinvars
carlosfg on November 17, 2009 ·
. I believe that being public about your life, disclosing your address, your location, your habits, and learning a great deal about the habits of others, is not necessarily adding risk to your life.
Of course you do. You are a narcissist so to you “disclosing” everything you can outweighs any potential risks.
Jesus on November 18, 2009 ·
I’d add that sharing your experience could mean a lot to some of us while offending no one. So if the risk increase is unclear and supposed to be small then it’s nice!
If it’s a big risk it’s like you, Martin, are risking your life for us! Isn’t that noble? =D
And btw, i’d like to see what other thinks about what’s the motivation some have to actually go to the personal blog/page of individuals they dislike to, well, throw crap.
I certainly stopped reading Chavez’s trash a while ago and never looked for any personal page of his.
Ivan on November 18, 2009 ·
As a Spaniard living in Madrid, I think that even that this is not such a problem as in Argentina and other Latam countries, I think the risk is there, especially if people think of you as a wealthy businessman. Best example are the express kidnappers, looking for fast and easy money. Just read yesterday this article (in Spanish, sorry!), it happened in Miraflores, not far away from your home and work:
Carlos on December 3, 2009 ·
What’s so dangerous about driving 200 kmh on german autobahns? They are designed for that and it is legal… The mortality rate by car accident is relatively low in Germany compared to other UE conutries.
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
guyon on November 17, 2009 ·
I agree with you. I think that there should be a semantic on twitter like RT-D-@ to highlight alerts, accidents and terrorism, and give it a 911 function.