Thursday, June 15 2006

Long Headlines of El Pais

Today I added El Pais in RSS to my Netvibes and realized that the Spanish headlines have many more words than headlines in English. I wonder if this is a matter of style or if Spanish simply takes more words to say the same thing.

Posted on General   |   8:17 am   |   Comments Comments(3)   |   Trackbacks Trackbacks(0)  

Share This   |   E-Mail This E-Mail This   |   TechnoratiOther blog comments   |   Digg Digg   |   Reddit Reddit

Comments

  1. Hi Martín,

    Both assumptions are partly right– Spanish usually takes around 15% more words than English to say the same thing, but it is also a matter of style. By comparing papers in Spanish from both sides of the Atlantic, you may notice the difference in lenght: American Spanish newspapers write shorter, more “telegraph-like”, leads than Iberian Spanish ones. A matter of tradition.

    Cheers,

    Pablo

    Valora este comentario: (0 votos)
  2. I think it has to do more with how the Spanish media sees the RSS feeds: wrongly. They think people only read the headlines, and they discourage people doing mash-ups of them. I have a mash-up of english news at http://say4.com, but when I tried something similar in Spanish, it ended up being a mesh (and El Pais and El Mundo specifically say don’t do it)

    Regarding your comment on the sizes of the sentences, some senteces can be said shorter in English and some in Spanish. Try to say “Envíaselo hoy” in english: “Send it to them today” …. :)

    Valora este comentario: (0 votos)
  3. I think by saying fewer words, you capture a more general audience’s attention, while a more descriptive headline captures a more profound attention from a relatively smaller audience.

    My guess of the reason behind this, looking at headlines in American news websites is that they want more clicks, just like most other things in the US, quantity outweighs quality. So many times I’ve been decived by some sort of undetailed headline to find the article’s not what I thought it would be and I it makes me feel cheated.

    I love your work, as soon as I get out of this boonies, I’ll be signing up for Fon.

    Bryan

    Valora este comentario: (0 votos)
Loading comments...
No comments rated yet.

Leave a comment

For non-related comments, please use the comments off-topic page.



 



Comment preview:

« Back to text comment

Links

TrackBack URL:

http://english.martinvarsavsky.net/general/long-headlines-of-el-pais.html/trackback
Valid CSS   Valid XHTML
Designed by Blogestudio
Close
E-mail It